You compare visitors insurance quotes and immediately notice the difference: one plan costs far less than the other. The cheaper option seems practical, especially if the traveler is healthy.
For people visiting the U.S., the decision might seem easy. Why pay more if you may never need medical care?, the decision might seem easy. Why pay more if you may never need medical care?
The reality is that U.S. healthcare costs are among the highest in the world. A single emergency room visit can cost thousands of dollars. A short hospital stay can cost tens of thousands. When insurance does not cover the full amount, the remaining balance becomes out-of-pocket medical expenses—and they can increase quickly.
There are two major types of visitors insurance plans:
- Fixed Coverage Plans, which pay specific, preset dollar amounts for medical services, leaving you responsible for charges above those limits.
- Comprehensive Coverage plans, which pay a percentage of eligible medical expenses, helping protect you from unexpected medical bills.
Key Takeaways
- Fixed plans pay a limited amount per procedure, not the full bill; you pay the rest.
- Comprehensive plans share costs based on a percentage of total eligible expenses, limiting your liability.
- U.S. healthcare costs can quickly exceed a fixed plan’s entire payout.
- Choosing a lower premium can mean a greater financial risk if medical care is needed.
- Understanding how a plan pays is more important than merely focusing on price.
Fixed vs Comprehensive Visitors Insurance
How much could you end up paying for medical care in the U.S.? The answer depends on whether you choose fixed coverage or comprehensive coverage, especially given the high US healthcare costs for visitors.
Fixed Coverage Plans
Fixed coverage plans pay according to a schedule of benefits, meaning limits per procedure.
Each covered service has a fixed payment limit. For example, a $50,000 fixed plan may pay about $330 for an emergency room visit or $3,300 toward a surgery. If the actual bill is higher, you pay the remaining amount. The $50,000 policy maximum reflects the combined total of all individual limits, not full coverage after the deductible.
A deductible applies to each event before the plan begins paying. Even after you pay it, benefits remain limited to the amounts listed in the schedule.
Comprehensive Coverage Plans
Comprehensive coverage plans cover eligible medical expenses as a whole rather than assigning limits to each procedure.
After you pay the deductible, the plan shares costs through coinsurance. For example, with a $500 deductible and a $10,000 hospital bill, you would first pay $500. If the plan covers 80% of the next $5,000, you would pay $1,000; the insurer would pay $4,000. Once that portion has been processed through coinsurance, the remaining $4,500 would be covered at 100% by the plan, up to the policy maximum.
What is a schedule of benefits in fixed coverage plans?
A schedule of benefits is a list of fixed dollar limits assigned to each medical service. Instead of paying a percentage of the total bill, the plan pays a set amount for specific treatments.
The caps are also known as scheduled benefit plan limitations. They define how much the plan will pay, regardless of the actual cost of care. If medical charges exceed those limits, the remaining amount becomes your responsibility.
Limitations of Fixed Coverage: Are They “Bad” Products?
Fixed coverage plans are not inherently bad products; they provide limited benefits in exchange for lower premiums.
They are limited in how benefits are structured and paid.
- Capped payments per medical service. Each treatment has a listed maximum payout. If the hospital charges more than that amount, the remaining balance becomes your responsibility, regardless of the policy maximum.
- A cumulative policy maximum. The policy maximum represents the total of all individual benefit limits, not a single lump sum for one medical event.
- Predetermined amounts. Payments are based on the schedule of benefits, not the actual cost of care.
- Continued cost responsibility after the deductible. Even after the deductible is paid, benefits remain limited to the listed amounts.
Should I choose fixed coverage for one parent and comprehensive coverage for the other?
You might feel tempted to choose fixed coverage for a parent who seems healthy and comprehensive coverage for one who gets sick more often. However, most visitors insurance plans do not cover pre-existing conditions, regardless of the plan type.
Some plans may offer limited coverage for acute onset of pre-existing conditions. In certain cases, plans such as Visitors Protect Insurance may provide benefits for pre-existing conditions under specific terms.
For new medical conditions, premiums are usually based on age, not current health. The real difference in fixed vs comprehensive visitors insurance is how much the plan pays when care is needed.
Comprehensive plans cover a larger share of eligible expenses, which helps reduce financial risk if treatment is costly.
Can I start with a fixed plan and upgrade to a comprehensive plan later?
Insurance plans cannot be changed after they take effect. To upgrade coverage, you would need to cancel the existing plan and purchase a new one.
The new policy is treated as a new contract, even if it is from the same insurance company. The terms and conditions start over again, including the pre-existing condition exclusion, deductible, and any coinsurance requirements.
Insurance companies pay only for new medical conditions that start after the effective date of the current policy. If you cancel a fixed plan after becoming sick or injured, the new plan would consider that condition as pre-existing and may not cover it. In that case, you would also lose the limited benefits provided under the original fixed plan.
The individual limits in a fixed coverage plan seem reasonable. Why spend more on a comprehensive plan?
At first glance, the individual limits in a fixed coverage plan may seem enough. The policy maximum may look reassuring. The difference becomes clearer when actual medical costs are compared to those limits.
Medical care in the U.S. can be expensive. For example, with a $50,000 fixed coverage plan, the insurance company might pay about $330 for an emergency room visit and $3,300 toward a surgery. If an emergency room visit costs $2,000 or $3,000, you would be responsible for the amount above $330. If a surgery costs $30,000 or $40,000, the amount above $3,300 would not be covered.
This is one of the practical risks of fixed coverage plans. The policy maximum may appear high, but payments are limited to the amounts listed in the schedule of benefits.
Why do I still have to pay with a $0 deductible fixed coverage plan?
A $0 deductible only removes the upfront amount you would normally pay before coverage starts; it does not change how much the plan pays.
Fixed coverage plans pay fixed amounts for each medical service. Once the listed amount is paid, the plan’s responsibility ends. If the medical bill is higher than the fixed payment amount, you pay the difference.
What type of visitor insurance do most people choose for parents visiting the US?
Many families choose comprehensive coverage plans for their parents. The reason is practical: comprehensive plans pay a percentage of eligible medical expenses rather than fixed amounts per service.
Fixed coverage plans cost less upfront, as payments are capped per procedure. When medical bills exceed those caps, the remaining balance becomes the insured’s responsibility. Those gaps are often described as cheap visitors insurance hidden cost, not due to unpaid claims, but due to scheduled limits that restrict how much the plan will pay.
For older visitors, where medical care may be more likely, families often select broader coverage to reduce financial risks if treatment is needed.
I have a claim under a fixed coverage plan and large medical bills. Can the insurance company pay more?
Insurance companies can only pay according to the schedule of benefits listed in the policy certificate; payments cannot exceed those stated limits.
If medical charges exceed the fixed benefit amounts, the remaining balance is not covered under the plan. The amount must be addressed directly with the medical provider.
If fixed coverage has serious limits, why do insurance companies still sell it?
Some travelers prioritize a lower premium and accept limited benefits. Fixed coverage plans exist to provide a lower-cost option. They provide pricing flexibility, with the trade-off of fixed payment limits per medical service.
In certain international markets, especially in India, fixed coverage has long been common for older travelers. Many foreign insurers offer only fixed coverage plans for individuals above age 55; in some cases, above age 50. US-based companies offer similar products to remain competitive and to meet that demand.
What do fixed coverage visitors insurance reviews reveal?
Many reviews point out that medical bills can exceed the plan’s limited benefit amounts.
Fixed coverage plans pay according to clearly defined limits. When charges are higher than those limits, any amount above the listed benefit is not covered.
These concerns reflect the structure of the plan, not a failure to pay. The plan performs as written, but the fixed limits may not fully match actual US medical costs.
How do we educate customers about the risks of fixed coverage plans?
We prioritize clarity and full disclosure, giving customers the information needed to make informed decisions.
- Clear definition of plan types. We were the first company in the U.S. market to define the types of visitor insurance plans: fixed and comprehensive coverage. We were also the first to create clearly marked sections for “Fixed Coverage Plans” and “Comprehensive Coverage Plans,” for customers to understand why one plan may cost $400 and another $1,300. Before that, most products were broadly labeled “travel medical insurance” or “visitors insurance,” making differences difficult to identify.
- Transparent plan summaries. When you search for quotes on the website or select “View All Plans,” each plan includes a high-level explanation. Fixed plans state: “After deductible, pays fixed amounts as per schedule of benefits.” Comprehensive plans may state: “After deductible, pays 80% to $5,000, then 100% to policy maximum,” depending on the plan.
- Side-by-side comparison tools. Customers can compare fixed and comprehensive coverage plans in detail. For fixed plans, exact payout amounts per procedure are displayed. Links such as “How Plan Works” and “Brochure” provide additional detail.
- Direct customer guidance. We answer questions by phone and email with clear explanations of how fixed and comprehensive coverage differ. We also share educational information on discussion forums and review websites.
- Acknowledgment of limited benefits. Some plans, including VisitorSecure, Safe Travels Elite, and Visitors Care, require applicants to confirm they understand the plan offers limited benefits before completing the purchase. After enrollment, policy documents include the certificate wording that defines exactly how the plan pays.
Are you recommending comprehensive plans just to upsell and make more money?
Our recommendations are based on how plans pay medical expenses, not on price.
Comprehensive plans are structured to cover a larger share of eligible medical costs. We provide detailed plan information before you purchase. You can compare fixed vs. comprehensive visitors insurance side by side to make an informed decision.
The decision is always yours. Our role is to explain how each plan works so you can decide which level of financial protection fits your needs.
What are my options if I disagree with a fixed coverage claim decision?
It is understandable to feel frustrated when medical bills are higher than expected. If a fixed coverage plan is purchased, the insurance company will only pay as specified in the certificate wording.
Insurance companies are not obligated to pay more than what is written in the policy. The schedule of benefits defines the maximum amount payable for each covered service.
If you believe a claim was processed incorrectly or denied in error, you may request a formal review with the insurance company.
Do you handle claims or review complaints?
We are not involved in the direct processing of claims. Claims are handled by the insurance company or claims administrator.
If a claim is denied or if there are questions about how it was processed, we can assist in reviewing the decision and clarifying how the policy terms apply. We review legitimate concerns and help facilitate communication when discrepancies arise. Our goal is to provide you with clear information and assist you to the best of our ability from the beginning.
Can't find answers to your questions?
Ask our specialists - Licensed and experienced insurance professionals in the U.S.
